Tutor or Self-Study? How to Decide on the Best Way to Prepare for the SAT and ACT

There’s a lot at stake when preparing for the SAT or ACT, so  many families wonder if they need to hire a tutor, or if their teen can do this on their own?

The answer depends on a mix of factors, from your child’s learning style and study habits to their testing goals.

Let’s explore the issues, starting with the common challenges of self-study and the unique advantages a tutor can provide. Then you can decide which way will work best for your teen.

Common challenges students face when preparing alone

Self-study can work for some students, but this method often comes with obstacles that can be tough to overcome. Students who can successfully self-study are often highly organized and independent. Even the best of students can struggle with studying on their own for tests of this magnitude. They can struggle with a number of things:

1. Lack of structure: Creating and sticking to a study schedule can be overwhelming without guidance. Students may not know where to start or how much time to dedicate to each section.

2. Difficulty identifying weaknesses: Self-awareness isn’t easy for anyone, let alone for teenagers who are new to learning about themselves. Many students struggle to pinpoint their weaknesses, which leads to inefficient study habits.

3. Overwhelmed by resources: With so many prep books, apps, and practice tests out there, it’s easy to get lost in the options and waste time trying to figure out what works.

4. Inconsistent practice: Without external accountability, it’s common for students to procrastinate or practice sporadically, leading to uneven progress.

5. Test snxiety: High-stakes exams can be stressful, and self-study often doesn’t address the emotional challenges of test preparation.

These challenges often leave students frustrated and stuck. Their studies may generate a little improvement, but not enough to really move the needle so they can have a shot at those reach schools. This is where tutoring can make a significant difference.

The advantages of working with an experienced test prep tutor

When students work with a dedicated test prep tutor, they gain more than just academic knowledge. They'll benefit in more than just one way:

1. Personalized study plans: A qualified tutor will assess each student’s unique strengths and weaknesses to create a tailored approach that maximizes efficiency.

2. Expert guidance: Experienced test-prep tutors know the SAT and ACT inside and out, ensuring students focus on reviewing the most valuable content and learning the best test-taking strategies for the test they are working on. And yes, the SAT and ACT require different strategies.

3. Accountability: A caring tutor provides structure and motivation, helping students stay on track even when their schedules are busy.

4. Strategic test-taking skills: Knowledgeable tutors teach invaluable techniques like pacing, educated guessing, and how to approach tricky questions.

5. Confidence building: A supportive test prep coach provides regular support and feedback leading students to feel more confident and less anxious about test day.

6. Faster Improvement: Tutors can quickly identify problem areas and provide actionable feedback, accelerating progress in ways self-study can’t match.

Tutoring isn’t just about improving scores—it’s about empowering students to perform at their best.

Should you hire a tutor or have your teen try self-study?

The decision ultimately depends on your student’s needs, resources, and timeline. Consider the following factors:

• Self-discipline: Students who are naturally organized and self-motivated may excel with independent preparation. Those who struggle with consistency will benefit from having the accountability of a tutor.

• Baseline scores: If your student’s practice test scores are far from their target, a tutor’s guidance may be essential to bridge the gap.

• Learning style: Students who thrive on interactive, one-on-one instruction will benefit from tutoring, while independent learners may prefer self-study resources.

• Budget: Tutoring can be a significant investment, but the increased potential for scholarships from higher test scores often offsets the cost.

• Time frame: If test day is rapidly approaching, a tutor can help streamline preparation and make the most of limited time.

• Stress levels: A tutor can provide structure and reduce stress for students who feel overwhelmed by the process.

Deciding between a tutor and self-study for the SAT or ACT is a big decision, but it doesn’t have to be stressful. Start by evaluating your student’s needs, strengths, and challenges.

For some students, the right tools and resources may be enough to succeed on their own. For others, the personalized support of a tutor can make all the difference in boosting scores and building confidence.

I can help students in many ways from a guided self-study course, to group classes, to private tutoring. Reach out to schedule a free consultation so we can put together the most effective study plan for your student. 

Whatever path you choose, remember that preparation is a process. With the right mindset and strategy, your student can achieve their goals and feel ready to tackle test day!